"Instead of stinging nettle, myrtle will rise" (Isaiah 55:13)
 "Instead of evil, good will rise." (The Malbim's Interpretation)
Myrtle Rising
  • Blog
  • Blog Updates
    • Privacy Policy
  • Aliyah
    • Mini-Intro
    • General Cultural Insights
    • School Tips
  • Kli Yakar Index
  • Most Popular
  • Contact

What We Learn from Why Shem Lost the Kahunah: Rav Avigdor Miller on Parshat Lech-Lecha

29/10/2020

 
In Rav Avigdor Miller's dvar Torah for Parshat Lech-Lecha: The Prince and the King, we discover that Avraham Avinu was a war hero.

The details of Avraham Avinu's military magnificence are never discussed much because, as Rav Miller notes, "they are unimportant" (which shows you Torah priorities right there).

But he was an excellent general & military strategist. He came home to a nation of adoring fans with all he won from his victories.

​Yet whenever we speak of Avraham Avinu, it's always about his spiritual victories—because the real gibur (hero) is the one who conquers his yetzer hara.

How Shem Lost the Kehunah

We never learn much about Shem, one of Noach's sons and the great-great-grandfather of Avraham Avinu.

If you'd like more insights into Shem's personality & accomplishments, you'll find them here too.

​Anyway, the original plan for the Kahunah (Priesthood) was for Shem to receive it, and thus all Shem's descendants (Nedarim 32b).

That's very interesting, if you think about it.

From the descendants defined by Sefer Yechusin, Shalshelet HaKabbalah, and Me'am Lo'ez (HERE & HERE), this means that not only the Jews would be kohanim, but also the Arabs, the Indians, the Persians, the Far East Asians, the Armenians, and some Turks. 

And initially, Shem received it. He also received the title Malkitzedek (king of justice) and served as priest to Hashem.

​Shem (as Malkitzedek) went out to greet Avraham Avinu on his return.

​Shem blessed Avraham Avinu with beautiful blessings.

In the first blessing, Shem said, "Blessed is Avraham to the God on High..."

So impressed by Avraham Avinu's accomplishments, both the spiritual & the worldly, Shem lost himself & blessed Avraham Avinu before Hashem.

He mentioned Avraham Avinu before he mentioned Hashem.

It sounds so strange. It doesn't even sound like Shem did anything wrong!

Yet that lost the Kahunah for Shem as a whole.

Here's Rav Miller to explain it:
A man who forgets about the Keil Elyon, the Uppermost Power, even if it’s just for a moment, defaults his privilege to be the progenitor of the Am Hashem!

The Chosen People must have Hakodosh Boruch Hu uppermost in their thoughts always.

It means that even when you’re talking to the biggest tzaddik; let’s say you’re going out to welcome the greatest rosh yeshiva and you’re dancing around him and singing, if for a moment you forget about whom you’re really dancing and you think you’re dancing about this tzaddik, then you lose out!

If you become bribed by his personality, if you become bewitched by this great man and for a moment you forget about Hakodosh Boruch Hu, it means that something is wrong.

And that was the error that Malkitzedek made on that day; for a moment he lost himself and he put Avrohom first. It was only for a moment – he caught himself right away, but for the one who wants to be the father of the Am Hashem, it’s not good enough.

The Real Greatness of Avraham Avinu

Immediately, Avraham Avinu responded (whether verbally or in thought): "Is it proper to
first say a bracha to me, and only afterwards to give a bracha to Keil Elyon?”

​And this is the real greatness of Avraham Avinu.

Says Rav Miller (quoting the Rambam's Moreh Nevuchim): Avraham Avinu never stopped thinking about Hashem.

And that was greater than anything else Avraham Avinu ever did.

​This is the great test in This World: Always remember Hashem.

​Whatever we're doing—no matter how mundane—never forget about Hashem.

The Correct Hashkafah: Great People are Ladders. Use Them Wisely.

You can read about how Avraham Avinu seen in his time.
  • He was extremely wealthy.
  • He composed many books, which people read.
  • He had tens of thousands of disciples.
  • He was handsome.
  • He was charismatic (in a real way, due to his saintliness & noble countenance).
  • He was a military hero.
  • He taught the Egyptians mathematics & astronomy (from Josephus, quoting Berossus the Akkadian).
  • He was very holy.
  • He was profoundly wise.
  • He was a Prophet.

It's easy to get lost in one's awe & reverence for such a truly great personality.

But Rav Miller says no. Watch out!

This is what we learn from Shem's seemingly innocent mistake.

A Tzaddik, a Rav, a Rebbe, a Rosh Yeshivah—they're all only ladders to reach Hashem.

Yes, we respect them & listen to them.

But at the same time, we know that Hashem put them among us to help us reach HASHEM.

Rav Miller loved all Jews. He loved chassidim. He never allowed anyone to criticize any Rebbe. He always crushed criticism of the Lubavitcher Rebbe.

He particularly admired the Satmar Rav Yoel Teitelbaum.

And here is Rav Miller's beautifully metaphorical take on the cause of religious infighting among Jews and how to prevent it with the right outlook:
​The truth is that you always must keep in mind that your Rebbe is only a ladder – the Rebbe is only there to make it easier to climb up to Hakodosh Boruch Hu.

But if a man just stands on the ladder and never reaches the shelf, then we tell him, “What are you standing there for?!”

There are a lot of people standing on ladders, and they’re all yelling at each other.

This one says, “My ladder is better,” and this one says, “My ladder is better than yours.”

So we tell them, “Get going already! Go higher!”

Once you understand that you’re climbing a ladder, then all Rebbes become “My Rebbe.”

All Rebbes!

​The Satmerer Rebbe! Ahh! Zol ehr lang leiben! He’s a wonderful man. A big warrior; and he accomplished for us so much.

The Lubavitcher Rebbe, zol ehr lang leiben! He accomplished so much and he’s still accomplishing.

​They should both be our Rebbes because they both can bring us to Hakodosh Boruch Hu and that’s all that matters.

Rav Miller was not a chassid, but a litvak. 

And he had appreciation, respect, and ahavat Yisrael for all legitimate Torah groups.

"Ladders."
​
That's the key.

A Kosher Wife Makes Sure that Both She & Her Husband Put the Will of Hashem before Their Own

Today, many women remain silent (maybe disapprovingly, but still silent) in the face of their husband's lack of integrity or whatever.

Now, if she can't say something, then she can't.

Some husbands are too combative, too corrupt, or too blind to listen.

It's simply not worth it for her to speak to him about what he's doing wrong; the price is too much to pay.

But if she can say something, she should.

Conversely, many women also do things against halacha "because my husband says so" or "because he likes this/wants me to do this."

The happens the most with regard to tsniyut, in which a great many married women dress with some lack of tsniyus in order to please her husband.

Another scenario occurs when the husband is such a great person. He's a great knowledgeable scholar too. His wife respects him so much—and for good reason.

Yet even then, she shouldn't blindly trust his judgement when she sees him doing something she knows he shouldn't.

​Even very great people can get caught up in their own idealism, and so on.

So Rav Miller goes on at length about how your husband's will should never come before Hashem's Will.

​Here's a snippet:
The answer is, that you should never forget about Hakodosh Boruch Hu!

Even the most pious wife who understands that a loyal wife bends to the will of her husband; and even when it concerns a great husband, a gadol, but still, he doesn’t come before Hakodosh Boruch Hu!

If something seems that it can be corrected, you shouldn’t keep quiet because even your husband’s great personality shouldn’t cause you to forget about Hakodosh Boruch Hu.

And therefore, because his wife didn’t say anything she was punished too. She heard; she was told what was happening, and she should have taken action.

She was a great woman; she wasn’t a plain person and she’d figure out a way to make a protest in the way that’s fitting for a wife with such a great husband.

Whatever it was, she’d have to do it, because it could be he’s the greatest husband, the gadol hador; it could even be Avrohom Avinu, but no matter, Hakodosh Boruch Hu comes first.

The Honor of Hashem Precedes the Honor of Parents

Rav Miller delves into the complex subject of honoring parents, mentioning ideas I hadn't heard before.

The idea here is to honor parents for Hashem's Sake.

Honoring a parent is about honoring Hashem.

That's why, if a parent requests or even demands that a child do something against the Torah, the child must not obey.

The refusal should be carried out nicely & respectfully. But the child should not capitulate.​

The Big Lesson

Finally, Rav Miller discusses how people interact with others in a way that prioritizes the person's desires over Hashem's desires. 

This occurs with lashon hara, chanifah (flattery), and other aspects we don't always pay attention to in conversation.

And ultimately, this is what we learn from the loss of the Kahunah from all Shem's descendants.

Instead, the Kahunah transferred to Avraham Avinu, from where it ultimately transferred to the descendants of Aharon HaKohen where it remains until today.

​Hashem comes first.

How the Baby Steps in This World Create Your Future World of Beautiful Pulsating Light

28/10/2020

 
While gaining a lot of encouragement from Judaism's emphasis on the power of baby-steps in the right direction, I struggled to understand how that worked within the context of the thorough scrutiny & Heavenly judgement that awaits every person in the end.

Rav Avigdor Miller enthused about how 5 minutes of a self-accounting becomes a game-changer, and also how thinking of Hashem for the amount of time it takes to walk from one streetlight to the next makes you one in a million and changes everything.

Or what about how 60 seconds can win you Olam Haba? (HERE.)

Or how Rav Itamar Schwartz recommends starting off talking to Hashem for only 30 seconds a day? (HERE.)

Or with Rav Bender's story of the crude butcher (HERE) who did teshuvah to the point that he died with "a good name" in his community. 

But the butcher never became a tzaddik.

And Rav Bender, who was a tzaddik & knew tzaddikim up close & personal, still seemed so content with the man's final outcome.

Yes, the butcher made tremendous spiritual progress in his life, but he never reached the elevated levels of Rav Bender and other tzaddikim.

​Yet Rav Bender recalls the butcher's final outcome ("a good name") with such relish & satisfaction.

How does all that fit into the ultimate scrutiny?

How can those minutes add up, especially with all the other distractions & tumah tugging at & influencing us?

​Can we really achieve a good position in Olam Haba with such small steps & limited progress?

The answer lies in Rav Dessler's Strive for Truth.

Creating Powerful Roots of Pulsating Beautiful Light

In the section on Being & Having in Part 3 of Volume II, Rav Dessler explains the connection between our good deeds in This World & our experience in Olam Haba (The World to Come, The Next World).

Gratitude plays a massive part in this.

Whatever gratitude a person cultivated in This World, it continues to multiply in the Next World...forever.

Rather than a stagnant world of pleasure, Olam Haba pulsates with continuously renewed pleasure as the soul experiences higher & higher revelations of Hashem's Glory, which increase the soul's gratitude, which thus opens up even higher revelations...all in a never-ending ascent of delightful self-abandonment.

(In This World, wild self-abandonment leads to animalistic behavior, which leads to terrible sins. But in Olam Haba, the goal is self-abandonment from the side of holiness, which means the nullification of the ego, which then enables you to experience maximum pleasure.)

In other words, Rav Dessler says that Olam Haba is an ever-ascending spiral of spiritual progress.

And that progress started down here.

This World.

This icky, polluted, stressful, exhausting world.

Basically, every single time you do anything to overcome your yetzer hara (especially with the awareness you're doing it because Hashem said so), you create a whole new root from which your spiritual progress can grow.

Every. Single. Time.

Because a Jew's entire purpose in This World is to reveal Hashem's Glory (something with which non-Jews can also assist the Nation of Israel), a single instance of choosing the right act over the wrong act reveals Hashem's Glory.

No one here generally notices this revelation, but it is certainly noted in Shamayim!

It happens whether you perceive it...or not.

This is very special, especially in our times when so much of morality is considered repugnant or on object of mockery & derision.

Have you ever been derided because you have a filter or image-blocker on your Internet—including by an old-fashioned middle-age aunt who should know better because she grew up with better values? (It happened to me.)

Why do you filter your Internet? After all, it only inconveniences you.

Your filter means you care about your soul.

​Hashem doesn't want us encountering certain venues of tumah (spiritual impurity), so you place a filter or an image-blocker.

In other words, you're doing it for Hashem.

And how many times have you restrained your tongue from anger or lashon hara?

Especially lashon hara to someone with whom you're genuinely close and would never betray you—that's lashon hara with no perceivable consequences. So why did you resist?

Only because Hashem forbade it.

Maybe a burst of temper would make things go better for you. Maybe you enjoy the cathartic release it brings (some don't experience guilt after their tantrum). Maybe your family or employees will get their act together out of intimidation. (Unfortunately, it works—at least for the short term...)

But you refrain. You overcome that particular yetzer hara.

Why?

Only because Hashem said losing your temper is like worshiping idols. It's a denial of Hashem's intimate supervision; it's the opposite of emunah.

And each time you do this, you create an invisible root.

That root definitely exists...only no one can see it.

​But it's THERE.

And in the World to Come, all these roots you created will combine together to form an unimaginably vibrant field of light—light that carries you on the journey of spiritual progress you started all the way down here.

Tzaddikim spend every moment making roots of light. So they experience amazing delight in the Next World.

But we can also do this. 

Those roots exist.

And that's why these baby steps, these 10 minutes here, and the 30 seconds, and the amount of time it takes to walk from one utility pole to the next—they all mean so much.

They all end up combining together to take you higher & further than you ever dreamed.
Picture
For more from Rav Dessler on how to do this, please see:
  • ​Rav Eliyahu Dessler's Visualization to Free You from the Trap of This Upside-Down World: Are You a Lowly Slave to Random Feet or...a Fabulously Successful Shoe Magnate?
  • ​​3 Inspiring Stories of Utilizing the "Instruments" Hashem Gives Us for Better...or for Worse​
  • Looking to the He'der Aspect of Gehinnom for Inspiration


The Generation of the Flood has Reincarnated into Our Generation: Here's the Evidence & Also What You can Do to Protect Yourself & Others

27/10/2020

4 Comments

 
Since I was a little girl, I enjoyed the stories dealing with Noach's time.

And they're even more fascinating now when seen through the lens of our Sages.

So even when it's not Parshat Noach (which really begins at the end of Parshat Beresheit), I'm still eager to learn about & discuss it.

​(All of the following has been extracted from the Me'am Lo'ez.)

Abortion is the Destructive Solution, Not the Compassionate Solution

The Me'am Lo'ez on Beresheit 23:6:5-6 discusses the people of that time—people we generally define as giants.

Several types existed, however this post focuses on one type: the Nefilim.

Chazal offers several reasons for their name. The root of Nefilim is nafal—falling. They were so tall, they looked like they were falling.

In the preceding verse (verse 4), the Torah writes Nefilim as if it reads nafalim—aborted infants.

The Me'am Lo'ez notes that with all the wanton behavior occurring in that generation, illegitimate pregnancies became common.

To save themselves from the shame of an out-of-wedlock pregnancy, these pregnant single women were given drugs to induce abortion.

(Modern society credits itself with the invention of a pill to induce abortion, but Torah commentaries show people already invented it thousands of years ago.)

So in addition to reading the verse as "the Nefilim were in the land," the Me'am Lo'ez reads it as "the aborted infants were in the earth": "The earth was literally filled with them."

This reminds me of the dumpsters behind abortion clinics, filled with the remains of aborted babies.

Pro-life activists sometimes sneak into these dumpsters to photograph the gruesome remains of abortions carried out on an unborn baby developed enough to adopt human form.

The activists are accused of using gruesome shock tactics, but they're merely photographing the reality of abortion.

(BTW, I'm against using the photos out in public, like on the sidewalk, for the same reason I'm against any gruesome or indecent image randomly assaulting the eyes of the public. But using these photos during an official presentation is correct.)

Another reason for abortion was because the regular women fell in love with the giants of that time, but could not physically bear such large children.

So they aborted them.

Pre-Flood Flaunting—Just Like Now

In the time of preceding the Flood, all sorts of immorality took place (sort of like now).

One bizarre aspect of that generation was that when they first heard about the punishment in store for their world, they responded by intensifying their corrupt behavior.

Again, this reminds me of the "Eat, drink, and be merry for tomorrow we die!" attitude prevalent today.

Also, in the "End of the World" genre, characters sometimes respond by committing depraved acts because "now's our chance!"

So upon hearing about the upcoming punishment, people engaged in every kind of depravity, including men with men or with animals. They even performed wedding ceremonies to legitimize these depraved relationships.

Women made themselves up and displayed themselves in the streets, seeking out wanton liaisons.

Men fathered many children without marriage, producing offspring all over the world.

Again and again, the Me'am Lo'ez emphasizes the lack of shame in that society. People did all the above without shame.

On the contrary, they reveled in their debauchery.

We see all this in our time.

For example...

With all the formality of the British royal family, I was surprised to read about the future king of England publicly shacking up with his significant other—the future queen of England—prior to their engagement.

Also, because she has since proven herself to be a paradigm of propriety, fitting so well into her royal role as Duchess-Princess, it's still weird to me that they were so lackadaisical prior to marriage—and especially prior to their engagement.

Yes, I know the royal families have always been immoral & hypocritical, but flaunting impropriety rather than keeping it private shows a huge crack in social norms.

​After all, "all the best people are doing it." So why shouldn't everyone?

What's more, you have all these European princesses willfully producing children outside the framework of marriage—their only concern whether these children inherit a title or not.

And with all the out-of-wedlock children & loose behavior pre-Flood, why did shame motivate women to abort?

After all, it's clear that generation commonly produced children outside of marriage.

Perhaps it's like today: An unwanted pregnancy is considered an easily preventable mistake in the mid-to-upper classes.

That stratum of society considers accidentally impregnated females stupid, not only because they got pregnant in the first place, but because they carry the baby to term when a practical "solution" (abortion) is so easily available to them.

So you rarely see a mid-to-upper class woman carrying an unwanted baby to term in the USA.

They either use contraception or abortion.

Attention Climate Change Activists!: Natural Disasters aren't So Natural

Hashem gave people many warnings a several hundred years to repent.

He flooded two-thirds of the world twice in Enosh's time.

He brought great earthquakes in the mountains, which placed the world in darkness—could this mean ash from eruptions?

He produced constant thunder and lightening.

When Metushelach died, the Sun rose in the West and set in the East (rather than its usual East-West path). But people insisted it was just a natural phenomenon.

He sent Noach to warn people.

But nothing helped.

Again, we see all this now.

Hurricanes, tornadoes, droughts, fires, disease, and flooding always bring calls to carry out useless gestures to reverse "global warming" and/or calls to impeach President Trump.

But these natural disasters never bring calls for repentance (unless you happen to be in a religious community).

The Danger of Too Much Luxury & Freedom

Despite the incidents of natural disasters, Hashem made life very easy and pleasant for people.

They felt rich, untouchable, and strong.

They scoffed at the need for Hashem, even to bring rain. Because they lived surrounded by an abundance of water wells, they felt like, "What do we need God for?" (That attitude is SO characteristic of today!)

They were strong—and also very healthy. They suffered no disease.

Wheat kernels grew as big as melons, then Hashem sent a wind to blow them off onto the ground so people needn't thresh the wheat nor go digging around for tiny kernels.

But instead of feeling grateful to Hashem for all that free time & ease, and instead of utilizing that ease & freedom to build a relationship with Hashem, people used these gifts to sink into decadence & depravity.

Seven days before the Flood, Hashem changed the Sun's path to rise in the West and set in the East.

During that 7-day period, Hashem allowed that generation to experience such great pleasure, it approached the delights of the World to Come!

(He did that so the destruction of the Flood would cause them even more distress, coming after such pleasure.)

This is also similar to today. 

Even though before covid-19, many people felt stressed out, but a lot of that stress related to acquisition.

The truth is that even poor people in America live better than rich people did 2 centuries ago.

Cars, electricity, indoor plumbing, supermarket aisles full of everything to meet your needs in all different flavors—even $1 stores provide so much.

And the Internet brought great pleasure straight to one's fingertips.

Free movies, free games, free music—whether legal or not, it's all there & oh-so easy to access.

"Hi, This is Cindy from Dor HaMabul Reporting to You Live..."

Rav Itamar Schwartz mentions several times Chazal's prediction that the Generation of the Flood will reincarnate in our times (i.e. the End of Days).

​(Please see page 10 of this PDF.)

I think we're seeing this now.

The similarities between their generation & ours are too great to dismiss.

Interestingly, Chazal also says that the Generation of the Flood has no part in the World to Come.

I guess that means they cease to exist, including on the soul-level.


But they exist right now. They're all around us.

The reason why we need to maintain this awareness is because the same people who set societal norms & values for us today are the same people who horribly corrupted the world several thousand years ago.

And they're doing it again.

These people have NO future. When they die, that's it for them.

Do we really want to get caught up with such people?

Where are they taking us?

Around 4000 years ago, these same souls danced down a path of revelry & abandon that led to unimaginable destruction.

And they're doing it again.

Let's step off their path & travel our own, even if our path doesn't seem as smooth.

Our path leads in the right direction—to Geula.

​Their path leads toward destruction.
Picture
Here's another link with a little more information on the topic:
communications-from-stars-or-angels-in-todays-ufo-cults-nothing-new-the-generation-of-the-flood-did-that-too.html
4 Comments

The Me'am Lo'ez on the Descendants of the Sons of Noach

26/10/2020

 
This post is basically a continuation of The Nations Established by the Sons of Noach: Where are They Now?

It's all based on the Me'am Lo'ez on Parshat Noach.

Cham

The Kaftorim (offspring of Mitzrayim from Cham) are the pygmies.

The Patrusim & Kasluchim (also offspring of Mitzrayim from Cham) indulged in the immorality of exchanging wives. From these adulterous unions came the Plishtim (Philistines).

The Lehavim (also offspring of Mitzrayim from Cham) acquired this name because their faces were like flames (not sure if in shape or some other quality). Lahav is "flame" in Hebrew. 

Kush, Mitzrayim, Put, and Canaan were the leaders of the plan to build the infamous Tower of Babel.​

Yefet

Tiras (Yefet's youngest son) initiated the custom of wearing gold or silver rings on the fingers.​

Shem

Ever (son of Shelach from Shem) was the biggest tzaddik of these offspring & he also possessed tremendous genius. Both these attributes inspired him to establish the incredible yeshivah in which our Patriarchs studied, commonly known as "the yeshivah of Shem and Ever."

Chatzermavet (literally: "courtyard of death) was the grandson of Ever (via Yaktan), who descended from Shem.

A nation of ascetics descended from Chatzermavet. The Me'am Lo'ez states they went around unclothed "like the Dervishes" and "were interested only in death."

Only recently did I have a clue as to what this could possibly mean.

Could this be the ghoulish Aghori cult on the banks of the Ganges River in India?

(For more on them, please see: How Going to the Extremes of "Transcendent" Spirituality Leads to Disturbing Death Rituals & Cannibalism.) 

This aligns with Rav Gedalia's theory in Shalshelet HaKabbalah that all the sons of Yaktan ended up in the East. While certainly there are countries even farther East than India, his specific term is that they ended up on the eastern "side," which easily includes India, as well as the Far East.

Please see also these for more fascinating analysis of who these nations are:
  • dinonline.org/2023/10/20/seventy-nations-of-the-world/
  • dinonline.org/2023/10/27/seventy-nations-of-the-world-part-ii/
  • ​dinonline.org/2016/10/28/seventy-nations-seventy-languages-then-and-now/


CUSTOM MADE – Nechumelle Jacobs's Poetic Glimpse into Appreciating the Good within Life's Grueling Ordeals

25/10/2020

1 Comment

 
This post features another poem by Mrs. Nechumelle Jacobs.

I love all her poems, but this one encapsulated all-in-one so much of what she has expressed in several of her previous poems.

The challenges of Cerebral Palsy (wheelchair-bound, can only used her right hand, with chronic pain in one leg), the forced dependence on others for things we often don't even notice (like how we're able to go about our lives without custom-made socks)—all this combined with a highly intelligent & independent personality, and her profoundly beautiful relationship with her husband—a man so special, he makes Nechumelle feel all her suffering is worthwhile for such a soulmate.

CUSTOM MADE

Because throughout my life, I endure a disability
My socks and splints are custom made for me

This ensures the fit is completely correct
As my feet can’t handle the slightest defect

It takes a ‘master of his work’ to do the measure
So that as I wear them, I do not feel any pressure

This thought occurred to me in recent days
Hashem custom-made my life in so many ways

He created my life with His guarantee and seal
He senses that my life is quite a big ordeal

So He gave me family and friends to help reach my goal
And since I married, I have my husband – we share a soul

Looking back throughout my life, this observation I truly got to see
The turbulent times gave me my marriage, despite my disability

©Nechumelle Jacobs – 21st October 2020

(Used with permission)
Picture
For previous poems by Nechumelle Jacobs, please see:​
  • "WE ARE HERE TO GROW" – An Inspiring Poem by Nechumelle Jacobs
  • Poetic Inspiration for the Day of Judgment from Nechumelle Jacobs: "SUPER SENSITIVITY"
1 Comment

Rav Avigdor Miller on Parshat Noach: Why Davka a Flood?

23/10/2020

 
In Rav Avigdor Miller's dvar Torah for Parshat Noach: The World of Nothing, the question comes up of why a flood?

There are several reasons why Hashem saw fit to wipe out humanity.

The most obvious reason is sin. Dor HaMabul was a very sinful generation.

​They led lives of ease & luxury—and they went against Hashem without turning back.

But He could've wiped out humanity with a pandemic.

Why a flood?

​Why a hot flood with upper & lower waters surging to entirely destroy everything: buildings, roads, utensils, structures, sculptures, books, bones, animals, orchards, fields, forests—literally everything?​

Our Fascination with Our World

Those earliest generations set the stage for all the generations that followed after Flood: techniques for sowing, harvesting, making all sorts of tools, making metals like swords & plows, making bread, horticulture, agriculture, weavery & textiles, and much more.

King Shlomo wrote that Hashem put the world into our hearts.

On the negative side, that means we focus on the material.

On the positive side, it means that we focus on the myriad wonders throughout the world—like the perfect miracle of an apple—and reflect back on the One who created it all.

In other words, we can use the world for physical pleasures & material goals or use the world for kedushah & spiritual goals.

​Our attraction to the world is either a trap or an opportunity; it depends how we use it.

Where is Hashem in All This?

In the time before the Flood, people became obsessed with fulfilling physical desires and material acquisition.

They tricked each other out of things worth less than a penny & fought over territory and more significant possessions.

​The Me'am Lo'ez says that wheat grew tall with kernels the size of melons.

Because of the difficulty of harvesting such heavy-duty wheat, Hashem caused a wind to come & blow out the kernels so the people could easily gather them from the ground.

​They didn't even need to thresh their wheat.

He made life so easy & bountiful for the people, yet they ignored Him.

Rav Miller advises us to include Hashem in our conversations more, like at the dinner table.

Even if we feel very religious & committed to Torah, Rav Miller suggests we examine how often we talk about Hashem—and how often we talk about business, politics, and other worldly matters without including Hashem?

And how much do we feel compelled to discuss our resentments & jealousies?

Sure, sometimes we need to get stuff off our chest. We need reassurance or advice.

But some of us constantly harp on the deficiencies of our spouse, in-law, parents, children, neighbors, co-workers, boss, and so on.

Appreciation or Obsession?

It's good for us to appreciate & love what we have in life.

But Rav Miller reminds us that we can fall so in love with certain aspects that we lose focus.

Our home becomes such a part of us that we end up looking to beautify it all the time.

Making repairs & keeping it comfortable to live & function in is good. That sometimes necessitates improvements.

But if you've ever found yourself thinking obsessively (as I have) about how you'd like to rearrange the furniture or add this and buy that and so on, then that's diving a bit too deeply into This World.

Yes, sometimes you need make calculations about your home & analyze a better design in your head, but not obsessively.

​Rav Miller also mentions obsession with work & hobbies.

Travel, art, sports, entertainment, cuisine, novels...

How many of us get so caught up in wedding plans that we lose sight of the very real kedushah of a new joining of souls who are setting out on a journey of self-rectification & mitzvot?

It's very normal.

Rebbetzin Tziporah Gottleib (Heller) once mentioned that sometimes women told her, "But with more children, you have more laundry"—as if it's not worth it.

True, the laundry can get overwhelming—100%! But Rebbetzin Gottleib emphasized the incomparable value of bringing a Jewish soul into the world.

It's so precious & so powerful—how can it be reduced to the amount of laundry that accompanies it?

​There are so many distractions—some under the guise of pressure, some under the guise of pleasure—it's hard to maintain the true perspective.

We all struggle with this on some level.

When Nothing is Everything

So Hashem brought us the Mabul to say that everything is nothing--hevel.

It sounds depressing, but that's really the meaning of Shema Yisrael, when we declare that Hashem is our One & Only.

​It's actually a beautiful, inspiring, and liberating idea:
Now, I understand that there will be opposition to this.

If you try to tell people these things they laugh at you; they’ll say it's extreme and that it’s not realistic.

​“You have to be a frum Jew,” they say. “You have to daven and you have to learn Torah and do mitzvos; but to say everything is Hashem and if not, it’s hevel?! Only to think about Hashem?! Is that a life?!”

And the answer is yes; a resounding yes!

That’s the best life, the most successful life, the happiest life.

The Holy Nutter

Rav Miller reminds us that when Esav asked Yaakov about all the people with him, Yaakov answered, "They're the children that God gave me."

This is the correct perspective.

An elderly Iranian-Jewish woman told me of when her mother held her newborn baby (i.e., her granddaughter) in her arms for the first time and just stood there gazing at the baby without speaking.

The woman told me in a voice full of affection, "I said, 'Mother, what are you doing?' And without looking up, my mother told me, 'I'm looking at nifla'ot haBorei'—the wonders of the Creator."

We're not so far removed from the people with the correct perspective.

​We sound silly or holier-than-thou or like show-offs when we talk like this.

But it's the right way to think.

As for how we should behave, practically speaking?

We need to strike the right balance between not letting others' opinions determine our behavior & not showing off or being unusual just to be rebellious or attract attention.

​Here's Rav Miller (page 18):
It’s better to be a lunatic all your life in the eyes of Mankind, in order that Hakadosh Baruch Hu should approve of you.

​However, take that advice carefully.

It’s a recipe for greatness, a prescription, but don’t just stam try to be a shoteh [fool].

But either way, that’s the ideal and we’re talking now about the ideal – to see Hashem everywhere, to see Him in everything.

Some Quick & Easy Tips to Internalize This Concept

Rav Miller details how to view eating, apples, bread, sunshine, rain, and clouds.

Life has a purpose, states Rav Miller. 

It doesn't have to be nothing.

As usual with Rav Miller, it's all about very small acts that take mere seconds to fulfill, such as spending 20 seconds to replace This World with Hashem—like when you see sunlight, take 20 seconds to think that Hashem is shining the sunlight. And do this 3 times a day.

​Here are Rav Miller's final words on the topic:
And because remembering Hakodosh Boruch Hu is the most important thing, it was worth it to bring a Mabul upon the world just to teach that lesson forever and ever.

The great flood came to destroy everything in order to demonstrate that all the things that people considered important until now are really nothing.

What’s left in the world? There’s nothing left to talk about, nothing to think about. 

Only water on all sides, just desolation.

They were sitting in the teivah [ark] and there was nothing to do except to look out and see nothing.

​And that way the progenitors of the newly built world would experience at least once that actually it’s only Hakodosh Boruch Hu that belongs in our hearts and with that understanding they would rebuild the world again.

If you daven Kabbalat Shabbat:

​When you say the Psalm 29 ("Havu L'Hashem bnei elim..."), and you get to verse 10 ("Hashem lamabul yashav vayeshev Hashem Melech l'olam—Hashem sat [enthroned] at the Flood; Hashem sat as King forever."), you can think of the image produced by Rav Miller's words above.

It's really good to do that because that's the meaning of the verse, which is phrased in a very pictorial way.
Picture

Part II–Beware the Government that Wants to "Help" You: The Exceptionally "Progressive" City & Its House of Horrors

22/10/2020

 
In Part II (here's Part I), we'll look at flagrant violations of the 7 Universal/Noachide Laws, plus why we need to stop focusing on gender & focus instead on values, evidence that no matter how much you blame immoral leaders, they still need the collusion of society to operate, why you should NEVER automatically trust the government & authorities, and more.

Note: Usually, I prefer to avoid names of wicked people as much as possible (because studies show it lends them a certain aura of importance, which affects society negatively, & which is maybe 1 reason why Jews traditionally say "May his name be erased" after saying the name of an evil person). But in this case, avoid names leads to confusion (because there are 3 of them). So I'll use initializations or drop titles, etc., instead.

How It All Began

In 1891, Georgia Tann was born to Beulah & George Tann.

Beulah respected in the community & devoted to her family.

George served as a local judge. A domineering man who publicly flaunted his infidelities, Judge Tann forced his daughter Georgia into piano lessons & hours of practice from the age of 5, insisting that his daughter becoming a concert pianist.

There was an older brother too, but it's not clear whether he was biological or adopted.

Despite Judge Tann's obvious flaws, he seemed to show genuine concern over abandoned or neglected children, often bringing them home.

The other alternatives at that time were either a child workhouse or a state asylum.

​So he brought them home. (The older brother may have been one of those kids.)

"I wish I had a doctor, a school teacher, and a far-seeing minister to sit as a committee and help me decide what should be done with these children," he often lamented.​

Highly Educated & Independent with a Veneer of "Helpfulness"

Georgia (from hereon called "GT") earned her unwanted degree in music in 1913.

But her real interest lay in law. 

She took courses in social work at the Ivy League Columbia University in New York, then studied law with her father and passed the Mississippi bar exam.

GT never showed any interest in getting married. (She only felt attracted to her own gender, and acted on this attraction for the rest of her life.)

But because practicing law was uncommon for women, her father refused to let her do it.

Instead, she became a social worker.

And that was the beginning of the end of the lives of many children.

Setting the Stage

GT found work in a Mississippi children's home.

There, GT adopted a little girl named June.

At that same place, GT also met a younger woman who'd given birth out of wedlock, but invented a new last name to appear widowed, and kept her out-of-wedlock son. 

Then she & GT ended up permanently living together in "that" kind of a relationship with the 2 children.

(Yes, this is getting weird for the 1920s.)

Here, GT first started displaying "questionable child-placing methods," which resulted in her termination in 1924.

In short, Mississippi parents who never agreed to give up their children took GT to court, where the judge allowed the parents to win & foiled what amounted to kidnapping on the part of GT.

And so GT found work in a children's home in Memphis, Tennessee, where she used aggressive tactics to take control of that home, becoming the manager in that same year.

Mass Abductions Disguised as Adoptions

At that time in America, adoption barely existed.

Before GT took over, there were maybe 5 adoptions in Tennessee throughout the entire year.

Unwed mothers generally married the father of their child.

It was GT who created the modern American adoption system. 

And it wasn't in a good way.

The best term to describe GT's operation is "child trafficking."

From 1924 to 1950, GT trafficked around 5000 children with the collusion of her motley staff and authorities like Mayor Crump and Judge Camille Kelley.

​While the adoption fee used to be affordable ($7), GT used lies & false promises (unfulfilled background checks, imaginary expenses, etc.) to elicit hundreds of dollars from wealthy couples looking to adopt.

In some cases, GT managed to earn $5000 for an adoption.

She took infants of poor, unwed mothers straight from birth without allowing them to see their baby even once, telling them they'd delivered a boy when they delivered a girl, and vice-versa, or claiming the baby had died—all so that they'd never be able to trace their stolen baby.

(GT obviously needed—and received—the collaboration of the hospital staff to carry this out.)

She lied to couples looking to adopt, telling them a child came from classy educated parents when the child was really from a backwoods uneducated family.

Jewish couples, who found it impossible to adopt (either because homes refused to adopt out to Jews or because so few Jewish babies were available for adoption) found GT willing to deal with them (for a high price, of course) and she sold them non-Jewish babies, claiming they were Jewish.

If couples wished to adopt a blonde blue-eyed child of, say, age 5, GT either went out herself or sent agents to scour playgrounds & streets for a child who fit that description, then stopped by that child in her elegant limousine.

In fact, GT specialized in blonde, blue-eyed children.

With her grandmotherly appearance & promise of candy, GT lured children for an exciting ride in her limo.

She even combed impoverished neighborhoods, looking for children playing outside on the porch.

At that time, it was perfectly safe to leave your baby in a carriage or crib on the front porch of your home (especially in those rural small-town areas), while you worked in the kitchen or took a nap.

GT lured all the unsupervised children from their front yard into her limo, even snatching the baby from its carriage.

In at least one case, the children played outside their home under the supervision of their oldest sister, age 8, while the mother was away giving birth at the hospital.

(Can't remember whether the father was dead or at work.)

GT took all the children.

If you can only imagine the trauma of the mother coming home with a new baby to a completely empty home, with no way to ever find her children.

In another case, a pregnant young widow took a nap while her children played on the front porch.

She woke to find her children gone.

Parents dropped off their children at preschool in the morning only to discover them "taken by welfare agents" when the parents returned to pick them up—in other words, kidnapped by GT.

GT also targeted children temporarily placed in an orphanage by parents struggling with illness or poverty.

Nuns who cared for children were forced to hide the children in attics when GT invaded their institution to seize their charges.

With her access to welfare files, GT targeted poor mothers, making visits to their homes & pretending to discover medical problems in the children, then promising to "help" the family by taking the children to the doctor herself & paying for the visit—yet GT & the children never returned to the deceived mother.

GT sold many children into child labor or to pervs.

GT falsified information & sealed documents or even destroyed records—doing everything she could to prevent biological parents, children, and siblings from later finding each other.

This system of sealed records spread throughout America, as did the adoption industry (although not as lethally or as abusively as GT's personal institution—although abuses still occurred within the nationwide adoption industry).

Myriads of Memphis children found themselves trapped into GT's children's home.

And conditions in GT's children's home later earned it the name: "house of horrors."

The Memphis House of Horrors

As no decent person would work in such a place (sort of like with abortionists; no decent doctor would work in today's abortion clinics), the caretakers were untrained men & women, who often worked while under the influence of alcohol or drugs.

Later, it was said that no boy passed through the home without being abused by one of the male employees.

Girls were also molested—including by GT herself.

Physical abuse was also common.

Hygiene & nutrition remained in a poor state.

​Children were given sedatives to keep them quiet.

And just when you thought things couldn't be worse...as per the fashionable science of the time (eugenics & social Darwinism), GT saw no use for babies who suffered some sort of defect or seemed weak or whom she considered "ugly."

She ordered her staff to wheel those babies out into the sun and leave them there.

Just like how the term "euthanasia" covers up the act of murder, this oh-so innocent act of wheeling a baby outside to "enjoy" the sunshine & fresh air covered up the intentional death caused by overheating & dehydration.

GT also devised ways to get rid of older children she found hard to place, but it's not clear how.

​When the poor hygiene of GT's enterprise caused an epidemic of dysentery in the home in 1945, GT continued to round up children—even when local doctors ordered her to stop.

​40-50 children died in that outbreak.

GT's horrific practices resulted in Memphis reaching the highest infant mortality rate in the nation.

It's impossible to know exactly how many children died in GT's custody.

Only 19 graves exist on the property because GT preferred cremation.

But some researchers estimate around 500 children perished under GT's custody.

How the House of Horrors Ended

Finally, Governor Gordon Browning (also a Democrat—let's give credit where credit is due!) overcame Mayor Crump's control and launched an investigation into GT's institution in late 1950.

​GT died of uterine cancer not long after the truth went public & so she never faced earthly repercussions for her crimes.

The house of horrors closed down.

Appallingly, no court ever launched an investigation into the black-market "adoptions."

No court ever returned any of the stolen children to their families.

Reunification only occurred decades later, when biological parents, children, and siblings decided to search for each other.

Traumas ran deep, especially in children old enough to remember their parents & siblings (like the 8-year-old twins sold to a well-meaning couple in California).

Debbie Branco was sold as a Jewish baby under the name Catherine Shredder to Jewish parents in New Jersey, then discovered her biological parents weren't Jewish at all. 

"Who knows what I am?" she said after the discovery.

Five siblings (of a family originally consisting of 6 siblings) found each other, but lamented over never finding the baby sister who arrived at GT's institution in 1945.

1945 was the year dysentery killed dozens of babies in GT's custody.

It's likely their baby sister didn't survive.

All in all, GT earned $1 million dollars from her racket—$11 million dollars in today's money.

Crummy Corrupt Crump

How could such a travesty continue for 26 years?

​A combination of factors intertwined to enable this horror.

And it had a lot to do with appealing appearances covering up a complete lack of ethics.

First of all, Memphis elected the Democrat Crump as Mayor and he maintained a stronghold over Memphis, serving more as a crime boss than a mayor.

Crump achieved certain nice-looking goals for Memphis, like giving black citizens the right to vote & paying their poll tax & providing them transportation to voting stations, he gave them parks & sports fields—all so they would vote for him & his policies; he didn't actually respect black people, though; he labeled them as "inferior," and so on.

He gave free milk to poor whites & political positions to young professionals.

Crump paved the streets, made repairs, & lowered taxes.

Yet he took huge bribes that allowed major illegal activities to continue—GT's enterprise was one of them.

He forced city workers to contribute to the fund that provided city improvements—pay or be fired.

That's how he financed freebies & obligations while keeping taxes so low.

He also set up a voting system that allowed him to know how every single citizen voted.

Any city worker who refused to vote according to Crump's demands found himself unemployed.

Those who allied with Crump found easy success.

Yet success came with a price.

In one case, Crump instantly turned one young attorney into a state legislator, and then a senator 2 years later.

But when years of not being his own man ate away at this attorney-turned-senator, he finally criticized Crump's poll tax. (The poll tax was a prime way Crump stayed in charge.)

When the young man refused Crump's demand to resign from office, the man suffered threatening phone calls & police surveillance.

Memphis society shunned his wife & the Red Cross refused to accept her blood donation.

As they walked along a sidewalk one day, a black sedan zoomed at the couple as if to run them over.

The man suffered a heart attack at age 42.

Losing their wealth, the couple moved far away & remained poor.

Crump became so powerful that other Tennessee politicians (like senators & governors) could not win without his support.

Initially, Governor Browning won Crump's support, which is how Browning first gained in politics.

​Later, Browning turned against Crump & won.

And that win enabled the shutdown of the house of horrors.

The Little Irish Jinn

Camille Kelley was a widow & former medical student who served as the juvenile court judge from 1920-1950.

While Camille's late husband was a lawyer, Camille never was. (After a few courses in medical school, she settled for being a housewife until her husband died and Crump offered her the bench.) 

Yet because Crump was in favor of women's rights (and because her husband was an ally), Crump decided to appoint Camille to the bench of juvenile court.

Again, appointing a woman to a high position, insisting on women's right to vote, & offering privileges to black citizens made Crump look oh-so progressive.

Known as "the little Irish judge," Camille rejected the traditional black judicial robes in favor of colorful dresses, furs, jewelry, and a flower pinned to her shoulder, saying, "Robes would scare the children to death. They're not so timid when they appear before me and see that I am wearing a flower."

Camille insisted on a balance between juvenile justice and sympathetic understanding for human problems.

She focused on taking nothing from a juvenile delinquent "but his mistakes."

She wrote books about her advice & experiences, and gave the books charming titles like A Friend in Court & Delinquent Angels & Kelleygrams.

Camille insisted on treating black & white children equally, seeking to improve circumstances for black children as much as for white children.

​She opposed physical discipline in the home.

Doesn't it all sound lovely?

Yet Camille also engineered 20% of GT's "adoptions"!

That means hundreds of kidnapped children passed under Camille's authority.

Later, Camille denied receiving any money from GT and even declared that she obtained favorable results in 85-90% of the 50,000 cases she handled over the course of her career—that includes GT's abducted children.

Yet how could Camille ignore the appalling high death rate at GT's institution?

The dysentery outbreak & GT's continuity of bringing children into the home at that time?

What about all the parents who sought justice in Memphis courts after experiencing the disappearance of their children—obvious abductions?

Records show that Camille also voided the rights of divorced mothers to enable their children to be placed by GT.

​It's appalling that children with 2 live parents who wanted them were forced from their home simply because their parents were divorced (and because GT wanted to make money by selling them).

I wasn't able to find more information online about Camille, but at least 2 books have been written that include information on her participation.

Regardless of how much Camille knew about GT's horrors, GT's crimes could not have occurred without Camille's participation.

Camille also died not long after the scandal broke, and she too never faced justice in This World.

The Respectable Grandmotherly Gremlin

GT maintained the appearance of a respectable matron who came from a well-respected family.

She lived in high style and associated with prominent members of society, including politicians.

She adopted a "needy" child herself and seemingly adopted a "widow" with a child into her own home.

Her institution was housed in a beautiful manor and her abusive, addicted, untrained nurses wore formal, impressive nanny uniforms.

She often insisted on these children from disadvantaged families being adopted into high society families.

One impoverished young unmarried mother, who willingly gave her baby to GT, boasted later of having made sure her baby went to a more privileged home. She remained proud of this into her old age, certain that GT was a savior who'd done her & her child a tremendous favor.

​(However, it's impossible to know what GT actually did with that baby.)

​GT appeared open-minded, willing to provide Jewish couples or established single women with children.

People saw well-appointed offices & waiting rooms on the lower levels of the manor, while the children lived in rooms painted pink in the upper floors.

​​While many children died of murder or neglect (GT refused to follow doctors instructions to give medication to sick children & babies) & while many children were sold into child labor or to pervs, many children were also sold into loving, upper-class, stable families.

Some enjoyed lives of privilege with nurturing parents.

With GT's impressive externals & her criminal strategy to provide couples with any kind of child they desire, she gained prestige by providing high society celebrities with children: Hollywood star Joan Crawford, Nobel-prize-winning author Pearl Buck, star performers June Allyson & Dick Powell, New York Governor Herbert Lehman—they all adopted through GT

They did not know she stole the children; she lied to them.

(Also, while Joan Crawford adopted twins through GT, her adopted daughter who infamously wrote Mommie Dearest was adopted from another agency.)

​This celebrity support also lent prestige to GT's operation.

It Takes a Village to Support Evil

In other words, external appearances looked so nice.

Memphis looked pretty & oh-so progressive under Crump.

​"The little Irish judge" looked so caring & appealing & competent as a judge in juvenile court. She even won awards for her work.

​GT appeared respectable, matronly, helpful, and social-minded.

With today's superficial belief that being a non-racist automatically makes you a good person, Crump's wickedness shows that supporting rights for women & blacks confers no halo over your head.

How did everything go so wrong?

It's similar to the Theresienstadt concentration camp, which the Nazis set up to fool the Red Cross. The Nazis made everything look nice. But it was all a façade to allow the genocide to continue.

The deception should have been obvious, but the people involved apparently didn't wish to see the truth.

And that's what happened in Memphis.

But Mississippi shows that it didn't have to happen that way (and certainly, not for so many years).

As described earlier, Mississippi refused to tolerate GT's methods.

The children's home, the social workers, the courts, and the citizens themselves...

GT's exit is described as GT "being run out of town" by Mississippians.

Furthermore, the children's home in Mississippi chose to provide for the children's family.

Meaning, that if an orphaned or abandoned child had relatives, but the relatives lacked the means to take in this child, then the Mississippi children's home provided them with financial assistance.

This was exactly the opposite of GT's method.

The Mississippi home acted in the child's best interests, even if they need to pay out of their own pocket.

Their allegiance was to the children in their care.

GT looked to benefit herself, and not others.

​Mississippi refused to tolerate it.

But Memphis accepted it.

And even with Crump's corrupt tyranny, Memphis still voted him out of office at one point.

Black citizens grew tired of his corruption & being under his thumb.

Everyone else grew resentful of his tyranny and corruption.

They ousted Crump.

​Too bad they didn't do it earlier.

Where the Path of "Progressive" Policies Really Leads

It's also impossible to ignore how GT's travesty came on the heels of Wilson's policies of racism & dominance & interference with rights on all levels.

The pseudo-science of eugenics (invented by a cousin of Darwin) and Darwinism (especially social Darwinism) was all the rage among the elite throughout Europe & America, both academics & the wealthy powerful magnates.

​It's chilling to realize that while GT murdered "undesirable" children, the Nazis also rampaged on a program of genocide against the Jews—and a program of eugenics which also saw the seizure of Polish children from their homes, the undesirable ones executed by injection or in medical experiments, and the blonde blue-eyed ones forced into a German identity & into German families—all very similar to GT's crimes.

​During this time too (1948-1954), the oh-so progressive secular Leftists in Eretz Yisrael committed similar crimes against not just the Yemenite Jews (although they were the main victims), but also against Holocaust survivors & anyone else they deemed appropriate to steal their baby, later claiming the baby had died and then adopting the baby out into upper-class families—if the baby was lucky.

Some met a more chilling end, if the hearsay is true.

​We see that sometimes a certain ruach descends throughout the world.

It may be supported & even promoted by the most successful in society, the most educated, and the most respectable.

​It may be backed by "science" and promoted through compelling stories & persuasive words, while also threatening with ridicule & rejection (or much worse) anyone who does not abide by this ruach.

And it takes a truly independent thinker and a true commitment to morality to resist being uprooted by this ruach.

What's behind the Smile & the Charity?

​If Crump were a politician in our times, mainstream media would revere him for his stance as a Democrat, his progressive liberal values, for his advancement of women's rights & the rights of black people, for his dedication to running a city well, his care for the disadvantaged, his freebies, and his low taxes.

Yet anything seemingly good he did was ONLY to keep himself in power.

Today, many wealthy powerful people speak of the poor, minorities, and women with so much sympathy. They spout "progressive" values. They run organizations alleged to help the disadvantaged.

But it's all a show. 

​(I'm looking at you, Clintons.)

​Today, GT would be lauded as a savior of children. A "brave pioneer in women's rights" for attending a prestigious university and passing the bar.

The media would admire GT's refusal to marry and also her attraction to her own gender.

But they were all terrible, wicked people.

It shows why you can't be superficial about trusting the government or the elite in society or external appearances & emotionally appealing ideas.

It shows how easily people can be manipulated into believing that something is acceptable and even beneficial—when it's actually profoundly evil.

(This same dynamic occurred around the same time in Nazi Germany, BTW. Hitler, yemach shemo, offered people free or affordable stuff, equality regardless of economic class, improved workers' rights & conditions, provided nature-outings for children, instituted laws against animal cruelty...and convinced everybody that if only no Jews existed, then everything would be peachy. The Nazis used science to back up their ideology, and popularized everything through propaganda. Everything GT did parallels Nazi ideology.)

Finding Our Way Out of the Evil Land of Riches

It's hard to sum up the lessons from the whole tragic saga.

(Except that maybe Rebbe Nachman already did it in his story, The Prayer Leader, in his description of the Land of Riches.)

It's about the influence of popular pseudo-science, and how that science infiltrates so many aspects of life—and is allowed to do so when people refuse to scrutinize what's being presented. 

It's about focusing on external appearances rather than actual values.

It's about wanting the easy way & settling for good enough.

It's about ignoring the 7 Universal Laws.

After all, had the mayor & the juvenile court judge realized their duty was to both enforce these 7 laws & punish those who violate, they never would've turned a blind eye to the horrifically high death rate in GT's institution, they never would have condoned the stealing of children (or, in Crump's case, stealing by forcing his workers to pay for stuff or stealing election, etc.), GT wouldn't have abused the children or allowed them to be abused, and so.

The mayor wouldn't have accepted bribes from the crime groups catering to human vice.

​If any of them had internalized the fact that every human being is a tzelem Elokim, the Image of God (and not just blonde blue-eyed children or the attractive strong ones, or wealthy people). 

There was definitely a certain ruach in the world at that time.

And we also learn that you can't complacently think, "Well, this guy supports minorities, so he's okay. And this guy supports career advancement for women, so he's okay. And we need women in charge because that's only fair."

It was davka men who fought Crump & shut down GT's house of horrors.

The identity politics played today, which encourages people to focus only on gender or race, proves deadly in the end.

We must only look at the actual values & goals of our authorities, and not meaningless externalities or fawning words.

Pirkeh Avot tells us: "Hechacham ro'eh et hanolad"—a wise person foresees the future results of present decisions & actions. 

​Only people of emunah & rock-solid integrity to stood up to the ruach of that time.

​And that's the key now too.
Picture

Part I–Beware the Government that Wants to "Help" You: Wilson's Policies & the Infant Care Program

21/10/2020

 
The values of American culture & the Constitution force the U.S. government to implement any program of questionable ethics in appealing camouflage to disguise the true intent of the program.

For example, in the 1920s, the U.S. government sided with a method of child psychology that opposed normal parental affection and the natural maternal response.

(You can read more about that here: The Past 200 Years of Chinuch I: The Non-Jewish World.)

Most oddly & disturbingly, the U.S. government distributed ​Infant Care pamphlets to doctors, which warned against “excessive” parental affection, advising parents to kiss their child only on the forehead and to limit hugs.

A lot of this was somehow meant to prevent disease and weakness.

An entire generation of young new mothers received these pamphlets with the stern warnings of how going against these stipulations would ruin their children, both in character and in body.


Though high school graduates of the 1920s were better educated than the average college graduate of today, these young mothers revered the education & authority of the doctors handing them these government-approved Infant Care pamphlets, feeling that both the government authorities & their doctors knew so much more than they did.

These pamphlets inculcated mothers with the belief that children (including infants) were manipulative and that tending to one's child in the natural, traditional way women always did would ruin one's child.

As stated (and explained) in the post linked above, I believe that a lot of the Sixties revolution was the result of this "children-as-manipulative-demons" approach to parenting.

When I described this government initiative to re-program young mothers against their natural instincts (and against generations of maternal experience & wisdom) to a chassidish friend from England, she grew thoughtful for several moments, then said, "I wonder what the American government's interest was in pushing this approach to child-rearing?"

The question of why never occurred to me. I knew it was all wrong, but why indeed did the U.S. government jump onto that particular bandwagon AND promote it so intensely?

My friend continued, "I mean, why would the government care so much about whether mothers rocked their babies or kissed them or played with them? Why was that so important to the government?"

I didn't have an answer and I still don't—though I suspect it connects to several nefarious programs activated around that time.

"Hi, We're the Government—and We're Here to Help!"

Woodrow Wilson, a dubious character, served as President of the United States from 1913-1921.

Initially, he focused on nature conservation (always sounds nice, but tends to lead to particularly fierce wildfires & the elimination of species) and set up a central bank: the U.S. Federal Reserve—which seems to be the reason why Americans ended up unable save for retirement on their own (inflation); once upon a time, you could save up.

​In general, Wilson sought to involve the Federal government (as opposed to local government by state) in all aspects of American life: banking, agriculture, railroad & roads, work hours, and more.

As lovely & caring as it all sounds, these policies and they way they were implemented are similar to what Hitler yemach shemo did at the beginning of his reign.  

The Typhoid Mary of Foreign Policy

Wilson also started intervening in the politics of other countries, sending American troops to Central & South America.

While this was always done in the name of peace-making for the good of those countries, a deeper look into it indicates Wilson's desire to dominate.

For example, during this time, Wilson managed to create the Panama Canal, which enabled new economic opportunities for the U.S.A. and also made it easier for the U.S. Navy to navigate between the Pacific and Atlantic Ocean. 

So that's at least partly why Wilson insisted on intervening so much in that region.

(Ever notice how extremely manipulative people always coo that everything they're doing to benefit themselves is actually all "for yooooooou"?)

He initially responded to World War I via neutrality & diplomacy, but when Wilson decided to enter the war, he set up an all-encompassing conscription bill to force young American men into the draft, with local boards set up to determine who should be forced into the military.

During that time, the federal budget soared from $1 billion dollars to $19 billion dollars within a 3-year period.

Wilson also increased taxes with the top tax rate reaching 77% and taxes increased on both businesses & individuals.

Wilson's Treasury Secretary came up with the idea to issue low-interest war bonds, but this backfired by causing a leap in inflation.

In 1917, Wilson created the first propaganda organization called "the United States Committee on Public Information."

To control free speech, Wilson pushed through 2 more Acts to prevent people from speaking against Britain or the War, or in favor of Germany.

(Even if you agree with those opinions, why enact them as official government policy? What if any of them were wrong? Why can't there be open discussion & debate?)

At the end of the war in 1918, Wilson called to establish the League of Nations to help govern the world.

Also, the post-war Wilson traveled to Europe and spent 6 months there, working out a peace treaty.

That would be inconceivable behavior for a President nowadays, but is even more appalling in that time of poor communication technology.

How can a President run a country while absent—especially in those days?

​Six months! (With only a 2-week visit during that entire period.)

In Europe, Wilson either participated in or orchestrated policies with negative far-reaching effects, such as forcing Germany to sign the Treaty of Versailles, increased colonization in various countries by foreign authorities, and the creation of new states (Poland, Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia).

(These effects were often only felt years later, and, for example, many claim the Treaty of Versailles had a lot to do with the rise of the Nazi party later.)

Not to mention that all his investment in "peace" policies did nothing to prevent World War II.

On the contrary, as in the case of Germany, his policies may even have contributed to World War II.

American Regression under Wilson

With Wilson's focus on everything except his own country, things started to implode domestically.

Demobilization of American troops occurred with poor planning; troops returned in chaos with little money or benefits.

Strikes in a variety of sectors occurred, some turning violent.

Race riots, in which whites attacked blacks, broke out.

Race riots weren't surprising seeing as Wilson was an unabashed white supremacist who promoted the Ku Klux Klan and supervised the racial segregation of the federal workforce.

In fact, Wilson's Presidency not only halted black advancement, but even eliminated previous strides made.

Wilson also hosted the showing of the pro-KKK movie, Birth of a Nation (originally titled The Clansmen) at the White House in 1915. 

Another disturbing aspect of Wilson's Presidency is that when he became bed-ridden from illness, his wife took over.

Throughout the autumn of 1919, she decided which government officials deserved direct contact with Wilson and all information & documents & proposals & bills went through her veto first.

Furthermore, Wilson's condition (about which a neurosurgeon later said consisted of "disorders of emotion, impaired impulse control, and defective judgment" after examining Wilson's medical records) was hidden from the American public, who had no idea that their leader was incapacitated and that the country was being ruled by his wife.

(This situation caused many to later say that Edith Wilson was America's first female President.)

Wilson wished to run for a third term (at that time, no term limits existed for the President), but by 1920, the American public discovered his incapacitating illness and wisely rejected him.

The end of the Wilson Presidency saw race riots, a setback in the previous advancement for all non-whites, vastly increased American global interventionism, new & invasive government laws & policies that could not be retracted as easily as they were passed, inflation, unemployment, higher & expanded taxes, the encroachment of Communism on within America, and general civil unrest.

Most notably, the deadly Spanish Flu pandemic of 1918 raced out of control during Wilson's administration.

Limiting All American Freedoms—Except the Freedom to Get Drunk as a Skunk

​Intriguingly, it seems that the only far-reaching Federal bill that Wilson didn't want to sign was the Prohibition Act.

Prohibition banned the sale, transportation, import, and production of alcoholic beverages. (It exempted wine used for religious purposes, like kiddush, or alcohol for medical purposes, etc.)

Nationally, private ownership & consumption were okay, although some local governments forbade that too.

​Despite the over-reaching invasive aspects that Wilson seemed to favor in every other facet of American life, Wilson not only opposed Prohibition, but sought to create a bill to prevent the enforcement of Prohibition.

Throughout my life, teachers & adult family members presented Prohibition as a silly act that everyone ignored and which only worsened things in America.

After all, my grandparents' first date together was in a speakeasy (underground illegal pub) in New York, something they mentioned with chuckles of pride.

(I also thought this was really cool when I was a secular teenager.)

In addition, I only heard about how Prohibition actually increased crime (at least, organized crime) and caused a black market industry to pop up.

Also, the production & consumption of alcohol (banned in some states) is understandably difficult to govern because it can be hidden so easily. (Unlike drugs, alcohol can easily be made at home using normal ingredients, like some kind of food & sugar.)

Economically, Prohibition caused the shut-down of many businesses associated with alcohol production, like liquor stores, refineries, vineyards, saloons, etc., (although Coors successfully transitioned into producing malted milk & porcelain, and grape growers transitioned into making grape concentrate).

It seems like violent crime rose during Prohibition, with some studies showing that violent crime, theft, homicide, and drug addiction rose during that time.

However, other historians attribute that to urbanization, which was also on the increase during that time.

It could also be that violent crime increased among criminals, but not in the general public.

Also, organized crime continued to thrive long after the Prohibition, as we see today, so it's not clear that Prohibition in itself caused organized crime.

While most historians agree that the beginning of Prohibition saw a decrease in all the negative aspects related to alcohol, the black market industry and its accompanying crime seemed to rise in conjunction with the Volstead Act in 1919, which sought to both enforce & intensify Prohibition, but ultimately didn't succeed so well. (Wilson also opposed this enforcement.)

Wilson's entire response to Prohibition is out of character because while he set up loan banks & government assistance for farmers (which ended up controlling farmers), he did not do so for the now-defunct alcohol industry, nor did he fund any programs for those seeking treatment for alcohol addiction.

Overall crime decreased 1849-1951, so some historians say this means that Prohibition didn't really raise crime rates. After all, the overall crime rate was on the decrease and continued to decrease.

Furthermore, some very real benefits occurred.

Some alcohol-related industries successfully transitioned into producing other products (like Coors). Grape-growers benefited from Prohibition, though not always for the right reason: Consumers bought the grape concentrate to make illegal alcohol.

Other industries also flourished, like the producers of fruit juices & soft drinks, who filled the gap left by the elimination of alcoholic beverages.

And the following decreased dramatically:
  • arrests for drunkenness declined by 50%
  • domestic violence
  • cirrhosis of the liver
  • infant mortality
  • ​death from alcoholism
  • hospital admissions for alcohol-induced psychosis
  • vagrancy 
  • disorderly conduct
  • absenteeism (people not showing up for work)
  • the number of prison inmates 
  • juvenile delinquency 
  • general alcohol consumption declined by 30-50%

​These stats are not surprising considering how often you see today disorderly conduct & vagrancy & hospital admissions in which at least one person is clearly intoxicated.

With a father at home rather than at the bar, controlling wayward sons no longer fell so solely on the financially struggling overwhelmed mother (who also not struggling financially as much as before because now she had a sober husband who earned regular wages—wages which were now available to spend on necessities rather than beer & whiskey).

So that's another reason why lack of drinking decreases delinquency.

Furthermore, with more men working stably (rather than missing work due to drinking or hangovers or alcohol-induced illness) and NOT spending wages on alcohol, people had more money to spend, which boosted the economy.

And it's heartbreaking to read that infant mortality was so affected by Prohibition. The implication is that drunk adults kill babies, and it's awful to realize that caretakers would endanger babies in such a way.

But the truth is that infant mortality went down during Prohibition, then rose again after the repeal of Prohibition in 1933.

In addition, Prohibition wiped out the entire saloon culture. It created a new form of socializing in which drinking played no part, and this norm continues among many Americans today.

Case in point: Until the 1970s, American drinking levels did not return to the high levels recorded in 1900-15.  

And while the American public later wanted Prohibition repealed (initially, voters were so happy with it, they voted in the Republican Herbert Hoover in 1928 based on his pro-Prohibition stance), a wide swathe of Americans had expressed concern for over a century about the effects of drinking.

From at least the 1800s, American women made a strong stand in this area.

After all, women especially suffered the effects of drunkenness: noise & violence of local saloons (which were also more prone to fires, which endangered the mostly wooden structures nearby), domestic violence, poverty as the man of the house drank away his wages, and caring for a husband in poor physical health who died prematurely due to drinking—not to mention dealing with sons doing the same.

Alcohol always did & still does play a part in social dysfunction: accidents, poverty, abuse, deaths, violence, and crime—so much is alcohol-related.

It's odd that Wilson, who intervened so aggressively in foreign affairs & invasive rights-violating government programs, showed such apathy in the fight against alcohol abuse.

With his love of government over-reach, he could easily have fought the organized crime & black-market industry, yet Wilson not only refused to get involved, but even tried to oppose the Prohibition and its enforcement.

(Note: A lot of well-researched information on Prohibition can be found here.)

The Liberal Lie: "I'm Only Doing This Because I Care Soooo Much..."

​Wilson granted women the right to vote, but with his whole "I'm doing all this for yoooooou" mask on all his policies, it's logical to assume that he merely saw women as potential voters for his third term (or for the Democrat party in general), rather than cared about the rights of women. 

(Or maybe his wife strong-armed him into it.)

Anyway, the final comment on Wilson is that he was a Democrat.

With the attitude of an autocrat, Wilson consistently ostracized Republican senators in every area, leaving them with little voice or sway during Wilson's administration.


This doesn't matter so much, seeing as Republican Presidents also instituted harmful policies in America.

However, the pro-Democrat media today, along with the pro-Democrat educational system (including the universities), insist that you revere Democrats as the great lovers and saviors of society.

And Democrat leaders like Wilson prove that it just ain't so.

Still No Answers

I didn't even mean to write a whole post on Wilson.

But looking at it now, it ties into the reality of a history of government policies presented as for our own good, but serve a more nefarious purpose.

Migdal Bavel (the Tower of Babel) resulted from government policy.

(A deeper discussion of that can be found here: The Kli Yakar in English - Parshat Noach.)

But today, we all see covid-19 policies instituted for our own good, but a deeper look shows the policies as either ineffective or davka infectious (as is the case in Israel, which necessitates that people infected with covid-19 use public transportation to go get tested in a public area; both actions spread infection rather than reduce it).

In fact, my children's school recently installed a large digital thermometer at its entrance (probably government-mandated)...which does not work unless you TOUCH it.

With around 1000 students, plus parents & faculty, how is that remotely hygienic?

Doesn't such a thing spread disease rather than prevent it?

Getting back to the original question, I still don't have a good answer as to why the American government decided to interfere so invasively in the relationship of mothers & children.

It upturned American parenting, creating a new kind of mother who now possessed a narrow, negative, & uncompromising view of babies & children & unnatural, non-nurturing mothering--all based on the theories of psychologically unhealthy professionals.

Even eugenics doesn't explain (at least to my understanding) why the government wanted the average American mother to behave toward her child in such a manner.

Though presented as for the good of the child, it clearly wasn't.

In fact, the husband-wife team Dr. C Anderson Aldrich & Mary M. Aldrich published Babies are Human Beings in 1938. This popular childcare manual brought the Aldrichs' experience as both parents & professionals. (C. Anderson was a doctor & Mary was a nurse, in addition to being parents.)

It shows good sense & humanity by professionals experienced in both parenting & medical care—and it sold well—but could not overcome the government's Infant Care programming.

That programming continued until the Sixties, which instituted a whole other attitude toward child-rearing, which sounded better, but reaped a lot of problems as we see now.


​It seems like the government's Infant Care program is an outgrowth of Wilsonian policies meant to invade & control people at every level, mostly for financial gain. 

But why did the government want mothers to be this particular way?

I have no idea.

Here's Part II–Beware the Government that Wants to "Help" You: The Exceptionally "Progressive" City & Its House of Horrors

Why COVID-19 is NOT like Cholera (and why we need to stop pretending it is)

19/10/2020

0 Comments

 
There's an article going around the frum community about the cholera epidemic in the time of Rav Akiva Eiger.

It's a fascinating look at how they responded to a deadly disease before modern hygiene and modern knowledge and antibiotics.

It also showcases Rav Eiger's wisdom & innovation in protecting his community against a truly dangerous disease.

The reason so many people innocently promote this article is because of its supposed similarity to the covid-19 epidemic.

But it's simply not a good comparison.

They're nothing alike.

The Good News: Covid-19 isn't Cholera

Left untreated, cholera kills 50-60% of those infected.

That's a horrific death rate!

Furthermore, cholera sometimes kills its victim within hours.

Meaning, some victims die a mere 2 hours after showing symptoms.
​
That isn't anything like covid-19.

Here's an personal example of a covid-19 outbreak:

Right around Rosh Hashanah, a group of around 20 yeshivah students caught covid-19 together. They'd been following the rules by attending yeshivah in a "capsule," which meant staying in yeshivah without leaving the premises, not to buy a can of soda or to go home—nothing.

Even going off the steps outside the yeshivah wasn't allowed.

The staff followed the rules of masks, etc.

But these young men still caught the virus because the non-NC95 masks simply do not work, nor do the other rules.

The young men subsisted on yeshivah food, no one even coughed, and the main symptoms were aching limbs, mild fevers, and the temporary loss of taste or smell.

As for treatment? No vitamins, no citrus fruits, no medication, no vitamin D or hydroxychloroquine, no ventilators, no special care—completely untreated.

(Note: If they'd asked for lemons or tangerines, they would have received. But they felt pretty cool about getting along in survival mode, so they proudly made do without.)

They fasted Yom Kippur and even made scrumptious festival meals with the extra food the yeshivah staff brought them.

(Yes. Yeshivah bochurim can cook—and cook really well! Some of them, anyway...)

Then after the newly instated 10-day quarantine passed from the time they got tested, they came home.

(No one gets retested; you're simply free after 10 days—which is nonsensical because there's no guarantee that a person is automatically virus-free after 10 days. If covid-19 was a truly lethal disease, the 10-day stipulation-without-retesting would be dangerously irresponsible.)

Interestingly, out of these 20 infected bachurim who went through a bout of covid-19 COMPLETELY UNTREATED...NO ONE DIED. No one even suffered complications. Baruch Hashem.

If it was anything like untreated cholera, at least 10 should've dropped.

​But as it was, there was a 0% death rate.

Likewise, in many of the "corona hotels" here in Eretz Yisrael, the guests subsist on unheated pre-prepared trays of meals. Many quarantined guests have uploaded impassioned complaints to social media, detailing their suffering and lack of medical care, without even a tablet of Acamol (Tylenol) available to alleviate their aching limbs.

Yet no one dies.

​Why?

Because covid-19 is NOTHING like cholera.

Just as a side point: Another difference is that cholera is a bacteria while covid-19 is a virus. Furthermore, cholera is rarely spread by person-to-person contact, but from drinking or eating stuff infected with cholera, like contaminated water or seafood.

Note: Please understand that I'm not pointing fingers at the average person sending this article around. They've been led to truly believe that covid-19 is much more dangerous than it has been proven to be. I'm concerned about why people who should know better insist on conflating covid-19 with untreated cholera—emphasis on untreated cholera; when treated, the mortality rate for cholera drops to less than 1%.

Also, I understand that in America, covid-19 has manifested in a particularly frightening manner—in New York in particular—with several respected rabbis from different communities dying of covid-19 in a narrow timeframe, plus people see ambulances coming to pick up people with severe cases.

That's not happening everywhere, so it's easy to dismiss it if you're not from New York. But in New York, the Jewish community is certainly experiencing covid-19 with more severity and it's important to be sensitive to that difference.

Having said all that, this still is nothing like a cholera epidemic.

What about Pneumonia?

In my area, we've seen hundreds of infections over the months of covid-19...yet only 2 deaths.

Both of the niftars were around 81.

One I did not know, but the other I knew.

He was obese and he looked & moved like other obese elderly I'd known who suffer diabetes & high blood pressure.

I was very sad to hear he died because I liked him; he'd always been so nice to children.

However, I also suspect that had the flu or pneumonia been going around, that might have ended his life too because people with his health issues are very susceptible to illness.

After all, while I don't know his specific health issues, he looked & moved like a very unhealthy 81-year-old.

By the way, pneumonia kills 50,000 people in the USA alone each year.

1 million adults seek hospital treatment for pneumonia each year.

In fact, within the 30 days of contracting pneumonia, 5-10% of its victims die.

Shockingly, it is the world's leading cause of death for children under age 5.

​This seems very serious. Why are there NEVER any lockdowns or masks because of this?

When It's the Cure that Kills

In any discussion of covid-19, I try to keep 2 points in mind:

(1) Despite the very light response to the disease in most people, it's still new and a light infection could fester into something worse months or even years down the line. If it's anything like its family of coronaviruses, then probably not. But it's true that we don't know.

(2) It SEEMS like covid-19 is more lethal than other viruses for vulnerable people (i.e., people with pre-existing medical issues, like heart trouble, high blood pressure, etc.). But it's hard to say for sure because the accuracy of data collection of covid-19 is questionable.

Also, with 50,000 annual deaths from pneumonia and the 12,000-61,000 deaths per year from the flu receive no attention, and so we don't have the same comparison.  
​
Frum media, for example, went out of its way to list the people who died (or who allegedly died) from covid-19. Pictures of relatively young people (with obviously pre-existing health problems) appeared in frum media to accompany reports of their tragic deaths.

But that never happens with more common diseases like the flu or pneumonia.

Not to mention, it also seems like many covid-19 deaths were treatment-induced—meaning the ventilators davka harmed people, hospital staff offered ineffective treatment, or hospitals even denied their patients proper treatment (via self-imposed quarantines, which prevented them from caring for their patients properly).

Here are a couple of reports:
habayitah.blogspot.com/2020/04/new-york-city-of-chelm.html
habayitah.blogspot.com/2020/04/our-mom-survived-covid-19-but-died-of.html

​That's just 2 examples. There are more.

Also, many reports state that the covid-19 numbers are falsely inflated.

​Meaning that if someone diagnosed with covid-19 dies in a car accident, then the death is reported as covid-19. If someone diagnosed with covid-19 dies of another illness, it's registered as a covid-19 death. Not sure if there's proof, but those are the reports.

An indication of this lies in an article quoted here:
havahaaharona.blogspot.com/2020/10/19-reasons-to-thank-hashem-for-covid-19.html

According to Shmuel Sackett's investigation into Israel's chevra kaddisha, LESS people have died OVERALL in Eretz Yisrael during March-September 2020 than in the last 10 years!

If the mortality for covid-19 was real, we should be having an overall higher death rate, not a lower one.

So it looks like the deaths from covid-19 really aren't as reported.

​That needs to be investigated.

However, it still stands to reason that we need to both protect and care for our vulnerable brothers & sisters—but we should be doing that during flu season too.

Why the Insistence?

There seems to be almost a willful desire to make covid-19 worse that it is.

After all, the article on Rav Eiger's responsible & insightful handling of cholera is both interesting & heart-warming.

However, it has nothing to do with the covid-19 epidemic.

​Yet it is being presented that way.

Covid-19 is simply not as lethal as untreated cholera.

So why publicize an event of a truly lethal disease as if it's related to a fairly non-lethal disease?

Why the insistence on trying to conflate the mostly non-lethal covid-19 with the extremely lethal untreated cholera?


0 Comments

The Nations Established by the Sons of Noach: Where are They Now?

18/10/2020

 
UPDATE Shvat 5784/January 2024:
​
Here are links to illuminating posts on who these nations are and also on the 70 languages. They're written by rabbis far more knowledgeable than I on this topic:
  • dinonline.org/2023/10/20/seventy-nations-of-the-world/
  • dinonline.org/2023/10/27/seventy-nations-of-the-world-part-ii/
  • ​dinonline.org/2016/10/28/seventy-nations-seventy-languages-then-and-now

UPDATE: I discovered mistakes in my understanding of the text of Shalshelet HaKabbalah.

Working from the online copy of an old text with old-time printing (see HERE), plus the random punctuation (periods in the middle of a sentence, or run-on sentences unmarked by neither periods nor commas), plus very similar spellings of different locations (-ציליציאה לידיאה-ליביאה, ציציליאה), plus unfamiliarity with these locations (partly because the geography changed since the 16th Century & partly because Spanish names are often used)—I admit I got mixed up.

For example, one part on page 220 reads (picture this in Hebrew that's not the clearest typesetting):
Chavilah are the nations of Yitula that's in Arabia Savtca. are the nations. of Astbray in Libya Savtca Raama Shva Dadon Nimrod Ludim Anamim Lahavim Naftuchim Patrusim Kasluchim from whom came Plishtim Kaftorim Tzidon all these are scattered throughout the towns and regions of that are in the kingdoms of Lydia Chet is the island of Piombino...
Clearly, it should be punctuated (and formatted) like this:
​Chavilah are the nations of Yitula that's in Arabia.

Savtca are the nations of Astbray in Libya.

Savtca, Raama, Shva, Dadon, Nimrod, Ludim, Anamim, Lahavim, Naftuchim, Patrusim, Kasluchim (from whom came Plishtim), Kaftorim, Tzidon—all these are scattered throughout the towns and regions of that are in the kingdoms of Lydia.

​Chet is the island of Piombino...
​Aside from the fact I've no idea what or where are Yitula or Astbray (or if those are even the correct pronunciations)...

Heck, you can find typos in my writing too, and I don't even have the excuse of using an old-fashioned printing press without spellcheck. So no condemnation of the printing here, just explaining why it was hard to work out the words.

So, for example, most of bnei Cham actually settled in Lydia (Turkey), and not Libya as previously stated. Apologies.

Thank you very much to the readers in both posts who left comments, which spurred on the double-check & the addition of maps.

Corrections (and MAPS!) lie below...

The Descendants of Noach

In Parshat Noach, we encounter the descendants of Noach, who went on to establish nations, some still in identifiable existence today.

With the help of Rav Gedalia ibn Yachya's Shalshelet HaKabbalah (Chain of Tradition), first published in Venice in 1586, we understand more about the location of those descendants today.

(Note: Though I tried very hard to decipher the names of the regions, I still didn't manage to understand all of them. So I only listed those of whom I was pretty sure.)

The first list originates in Sefer Yechusin, but quoted in Shalshelet HaKabbalah.

Lineage according to Sefer Yechusin as quoted in Shalshelet HaKabbalah

Bnei Yafet (Japheth)

First of all, he writes that bnei Yafet took the area of Lusitania, which today is where part of Portugal & Western Spain lie.

Gomer & Magog are a part of Medea called Shirvan. (Shirvan lies in today's northeastern Iran.)

Yavan is Greece.

Tuval is Spain.

Meshech is the Kingdom of Persia. (In the 1586, this included Iran, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Afghanistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Tajikstan, and parts of Iraq, Pakistan, and even China.)

Tiras stretches from Venice until Hungary.

Rifat is England & possibly Troynes in France: "Inglaterra and Troyne (טרוייני)".

Gomer is Ashkenaz (Germany) and its capital is Bohemia. (Bohemia was a kingdom that encompasses at least the Czech Republic today & lay under Habsburg rule in Rav Gedalia's time.)

Torgemah is Turkey.

Tarshish is a region called Cilicia in southeastern Turkey. (But some say Tarshish is Sicily.)

Dodanim is Rhodes.

Bnei Cham (Ham)

Kush is the "kingdom of the blacks."

Sava & Shva (Sheba) are the kingdom of Greece. (Yeah, that surprised me too. I was sure they'd be labeled as somewhere in Africa.)

Put is Libya & Nineveh (Iraq), close to Ashur (Syria).

Patros & Caphtor extend from Gaza until Egypt.

Girgashi is Gurjistan (Georgia in Russia today).

Lineage according to the Author of Shalshelet HaKabbalah

​Here, Rav Gedalia of Shalshelet HaKabbalah says where he thinks these nations are in his time:

Bnei Shem

Elam is in the Kingdom of Persia.


Ashur is Syria "and Arpachshad is near it."

Aram is Damascus.

Lud is possibly Lydia, in Turkey.


Utz is near the land of Canaan.

Chol is Armenia.

Gether is Carmania (Kermen in Iran).

Mash is "Meyuni" (מיאוני) (not sure where that is & not sure why I initially assumed it was Greece).

All the descendants of Yaktan (from Shelach) settled in the countries in the East.

Midyan & Afar are "the children of Avraham Avinu in the kingdom of Africa."
​
Bnei Yafet (Japehth)

Gomer is Galatia (Anapoli in Turkey).

Magog is a place called "Shetia," possibly in Iraq.

Medai is Medea (Iran).

Yavan is Grazia (an island near Italy).

Tuval is Spain.

Meshech is Cappadocia (in Turkey) "near Armenia."

Tiras is possibly Thrace, an ancient region that today includes parts of Bulgaria, Greece, and Turkey.

Ashkenaz is Tartary (which is weird because that includes Mongolia, so maybe I misunderstood where Tartarzia is.)


The descendants of Rifat ended up in Venice after first settling in a place called "Dypia" (דיפיאה).

Torgemah is Prague.

Bnei Cham (Ham)

Kush is Ethiopia.

Mitzrayim is Egypt.

Put is Libya.

Canaan is "Palestiana, near Eretz Yisrael."

Sava is Arabia.

Chavilah ended up being a group of nations in Arabia.

Savtca is a group within Libya.

In general, he says, the descendants of Kush are scattered throughout the towns and regions of the Kingdom of Lydia (which is western Turkey today) in his time.

Here is the specific sons of Kush who settled Lydia:
  • Savtca (who also ended up in Libya, not just Lydia)
  • Raama
  • Shva
  • Dadon
  • Nimrod
  • Ludim
  • Anamim 
  • Lahavim
  • Naftuchim
  • Patrusim
  • Kasluchim ("from whom came Plishtim")
  • Kaftorim
  • Tzidon

Chet is the island Piombino in Northern Italy.

Chivi is near Lebanon.

Sini is Tripoli.

Chiti & Emori are close to Yerushalayim.

​Yevusi is Yerushalayim.

Emori, Girgashi, Chivi, Sini, Arvadi, Arki, Tzamari, and Chamat were scattered throughout Eretz Yisrael, and "uprooted from the world by Bnei Yisrael."

Maps of Old Turkey, Modern Turkey, Europe, and the Sardis Synagogue

Here are some maps to help us better understand the locations.

Here is a map of 15th-century Turkey, not long before the publishing of Shalshelet HaKabbalah.

​You can see Thrace in the upper left, Capadocia in the upper right, plus Lydia (under ASIA MINOR) and Cilicia (down at the bottom, not far above Syria), among a lot of other places:
Picture
CC BY-SA 2.5, Link

Here's another map, with Lydia marked in red and Cilicia over on the far right.
Picture
By Mossmaps - This file was derived from:  Western part of the Achaemenid Empire.jpg, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=75086798

Here's the ancient Sardis synagogue in Lydia:
Picture
By Carole Raddato from FRANKFURT, Germany - Sardis Synagogue, late 3rd century AD, Sardis, Lydia, Turkey, CC BY-SA 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=45906673

Here you can see the Habsburg domains from the year 1700, including nations mentioned in the post, like Hungary, Bohemia (in yellow bordering Poland), Sicily, and more.
Picture
By Habsbourg-1700.png: Katepanomegasderivative work: Alphathon - This file was derived from:  Habsbourg-1700.png:, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=25542094

Europe (including Turkey) today:
Picture
By Grossgliederung_Europas.svg: NordNordWestderivative work: Dch (talk) - Grossgliederung_Europas.svg, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=8914026

Here is a map of Safavid Persia from the 15th Century (not long before the time of Shalshelet HaKabbalah).

Here, you see Armenia, Shirvan (on the coast of the Caspian Sea), and Kerman below in the mustard color.
Picture
CC BY-SA 2.5, Link

Here's an old map that shows you a wide swathe of the areas mentioned in this post: Lydia (Lydie), Cilicia (Cilicie), Medea (Medes), (sorry it's all in French, couldn't find it in English, but I think it's close enough to English that it's still comprehensible):
Picture
By Empire_neo_babyloien.svg: *Middle_East_topographic_map-blank.svg: Sémhur (talk)derivative work: Zunkir (talk)derivative work: Zunkir (talk) - Empire_neo_babyloien.svg, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=12098149

Here's a modern map of the whole region mentioned in the post:
Picture

Ancestral Opinions of Other Sources

​Then he quotes others who say the following: 

​Rifat is the Aeolian Islands (near Italy).

​There's a tradition that the inhabitants of Ashkenaz are the Canaanites who fled before Yehoshua.

Also, Josephus says that Tarshish is Tuscany (central Italy), but others say that Tarshish is Tunis, while still others say it's Carthage (a coastal region within present-day Tunisia) in Africa.

The Targum Yerushalmit states that the "daughter of Edom residing in the land of Utz is Armenia."

Some say Yafet is France & Britain.

Some say Tuval is Pisa.

​Some say Tiras is Russia.

A commentary on Daniel states that Cutim is Rome, the kingdoms of Greece & Rome as one.


Elisha is Borgonia (Borgoñá), which is today in Gerona, Spain.

Apparently, Rebbi Shmuel says that Gomer & Magog are Africa, Zarmenia, Medea, Mokdonia, Aisania, and Tunia.

We know what Africa is.

Medea is a region which is today northern & western Iran.

Mokdonia is Macedonia, a region in modern Greece.

Aisania is presumably Asia.

And as for Tunia? Today, there is a region in Pakistan called Tunia Baqa Shah, but I don't know if that's it, but it makes sense seeing as Pakistan is in southeast Asia and borders on Iran, south of Medea, which lies in the same region as the others listed here.


But I couldn't figure out "Zarmenia."

Final Comments

Some are missing because I simply didn't know what some of the areas were. For example, he says that some say that Tiras is "Unglakira" and Russia.

What is Unglakira? Probably one of the countries bordering Russia at that time, but I couldn't figure out which one.

Also, it's interesting to note above the general location of Tarshish, which is where Yonah Hanavi intended to sail.

It was apparently either somewhere in Italy or in Tunisia, which isn't so far from Italy—just on the other side of the Mediterranean Sea.

When he names the location of Ashkenaz, he calls it "Alemania"—which is the Spanish name for Germany. 

The Gemara also states the location of Ashkenaz as "Germamia."

It's interesting also to note that Germany consists of the descendants of Ashkenaz (via Gomer from Yafet) and also the Canaanites.

Seeing as Chazal identifies Amalek in their time as "Germamia" (Germany), it's interesting to think that the people in the German region comprise a mix of Amalek and Canaanites.

Canaan was a very icky, immoral, human-sacrificing nation in ancient times.

And though the Americas had been discovered in his time, Shalshelet HaKabbalah doesn't mention the American continent in his list. Or perhaps he did, and I simply didn't understand the term he used.

​Europeans only discovered Australia and the rest of Oceania after his time, so these are not mentioned either.

Anyway, this sums up the Shalshelet HaKabbalah's tracing of the descendants of Noach.

For the commentary of the Me'am Lo'ez on who these descendants became please see:
  • The Me'am Lo'ez on the Descendants of the Sons of Noach

<<Previous
    Privacy Policy



    Feedburner subscription no longer in operation. Sorry!

    Myrtle Rising

    I'm a middle-aged housewife and mother in Eretz Yisrael who likes to read and write a lot.


    Picture
    Sample Chapters

    Categories

    All
    Aliyah
    Anti Jewish Bigotry
    Astronomy
    Bilvavi
    Book Review
    Books
    Chagim/Holidays
    Chinuch
    Coronavirus
    Dictionaries
    Emuna
    Eretz Yisrael
    Erev Rav
    Gender
    Hitbodedut
    "If The Torah..."
    Jewish Astrology
    Kav Hayashar
    Kli Yakar
    Lashon Hara
    Love
    Me'am Loez
    Minchat Yehudah
    Mishlei/Proverbs
    Netivot Shalom
    Parenting
    Parsha
    Pele Yoetz
    Perek Shira
    Pesach
    Politics
    Prayer
    Purim
    Rav Avigdor Miller
    Rav L.Y. Bender
    Recipes
    "Regular" Jews
    Rosh Hashanah
    Society
    Sukkot
    Tammuz
    Technology
    Tehillim/Psalms
    Teshuvah
    The Lost Princess
    Tisha B'Av
    USA Scary Direction
    Women
    Yom Kippur

    Jewish Interest

    Daf Yomi Review
    Esser Agaroth
    Going...Habayitah
    Halacha Q&A
    ​
    Hava haAharona
    ​
    Jewish Home News
    Mevakesh Lev

    Miriam Adahan
    MKY Moments
    My Perspective

    Shirat Devorah
    ​Sultan Knish
    Tomer Devorah
    Toras Avigdor
    Tznius Blog

    Yeranen Yaakov

    Archives

    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015

    RSS Feed

    Copyright Notice

    ©2015-2027 Myrtle Rising
    Excerpts and links may be used without express permission as long as a link is provided back to the appropriate Myrtle Rising page.

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos from Brett Jordan, BAMCorp, Abode of Chaos, Michele Dorsey Walfred, marklordphotography, M.Burak Erbaş, torbakhopper, jhritz, Rina Pitucci (Tilling 67), Svadilfari, kum111, Tim simpson1, FindYourSearch, allispossible.org.uk, Giorgio Galeotti, ChrisYunker, Jaykhuang, YourCastlesDecor, bluebirdsandteapots, Natalia Medd, Stefans02, Israel_photo_gallery, Commander, U.S. 7th Fleet, BradPerkins, zeevveez, dfarrell07, h.koppdelaney, Edgardo W. Olivera, zeevveez, mtchlra, Liz | populational, TraumaAndDissociation, thinboyfatter, garofalo.christina, skpy, Free Grunge Textures - www.freestock.ca, Nerru, Gregory "Slobirdr" Smith, trendingtopics, dolbinator1000, zeevveez, erix!, zeevveez, h.koppdelaney, MAURO CATEB, keepitsurreal, annikaleigh, bjornmeansbear, publicdomainphotography, Leonard J Matthews, Exile on Ontario St, Nicholas_T, marcoverch, planman, PhilWolff, j_lai, t.kunikuni, zeevveez, Ian W Scott, Brett Jordan, RonAlmog, Bob Linsdell, NASA Goddard Photo and Video, aaron_anderer, ** RCB **, Tony Webster, mypubliclands, AntonStetner, Zachi Evenor, MrJamesBaker, sammydavisdog, Frode Ramone, Wonder woman0731, wrachele, kennethkonica, Skall_Edit, Pleuntje, Rennett Stowe, *S A N D E E P*, symphony of love, Arya Ziai, ePublicist, Enokson, Art4TheGlryOfGod, seaternity, Andrew Tarvin, Thad Zajdowicz, zeevveez, Iqbal Osman1, Matt From London, Tribes of the World, Eric Kilby, miracle design, RonAlmog, slgckgc, Kim Scarborough, DonkeyHotey, Mike Licht, NotionsCapital.com, h.koppdelaney, gleonhard, Pedro Travassos, nociveglia, RonAlmog, Israel_photo_gallery, Septemia, MAD Hippies Life, Neta Bartal, milesgehm, shooting brooklyn, RonAlmog, smilygrl, gospelportals, leighblackall, symensphotographie, zeevveez, Kyknoord, wotashot (taking a break), FindYourSearch, Tambako the Jaguar, bitmask, Arnie Sacknooson, mattymatt, Rob Swystun, zeevveez, Dun.can, Tim Patterson, timeflicks, garlandcannon, HRYMX, fred_v, zeevveez, Ron Cogswell, FindYourSearch, Israel_photo_gallery, Serendipity Diamonds, zeevveez, Steve Corey, Dominic's pics, leighklotz, Stefans02, dannyman, RonAlmog, Stephen O, RonAlmog, Tips For Travellers, Futurilla, Bob Linsdell, symphony of love, andydr, Gamma Man, Mike Licht, NotionsCapital.com, robef, European Southern Observatory, Brett Jordan, Johnny Silvercloud, Israel_photo_gallery, smkybear, --Sam--, Selena Sheridan, D'oh Boy, campbelj45ca, 19melissa68, entirelysubjective, Leimenide, Brett Jordan, HonestReporting.com, Iqbal Osman1, One Way Stock, Jake Waage, picto:graphic, Marcelo Alves, KAZVorpal, Sparkle Motion, Brett Jordan, Ambernectar 13, Howdy, I'm H. Michael Karshis, Steven DuBois, Cristian V., tortuga767, Jake Cvnningham, D'oh Boy, Eric Kilby, quinn.anya, Cachecope Bell, Lorie Shaull, One Way Stock, Bird Eye, Mike Licht, NotionsCapital.com, Kevin M. Gill, lunar caustic, gerrybuckel, quinn.anya, kayugee, jintae kim's photography, Futurilla, terri_bateman, Amydeanne, Mulling it Over, Ungry Young Man, Ruth and Dave, yangouyang374, symphony of love, kennethkonica, young@art, Brett Jordan, slgckgc, rkimpeljr, TooFarNorth, D'oh Boy, Grace to You, LittleStuff.me, Kevin M. Gill, philozopher, Alan Cleaver, crazyoctopus, d_vdm, tonynetone, penjelly, JohnE777, hello-julie, DaveBleasdale, byzantiumbooks, Nina A. J. G., zeevveez, Ignacio Sanz, zeevveez, Luiz Pantoja, CreditDebitPro, AZRainman, Carrie_Baughcum, Maria Eklind, Tribes of the World, mugwumpian, garryknight, Faith @101, Joybot, apollodiamonds, Patty Mooney, Leonard J Matthews, EUMETSAT, Corey Ann, jdlasica, josecdimas, zeevveez, sachac, Fred:, symphony of love, Yair Aronshtam, {Guerrilla Futures | Jason Tester}, europeanspaceagency, Pintanescu, xiquinhosilva, fontplaydotcom, Jason Rosenberg, amira_a, redfoxinict, anttilipponen, evelynlimcoach, SanFranAnnie, anomalous4, Diganta Talukdar, Deanster1983 who's mostly off, Five Furlongs, Iqbal Osman1, andydr, Adam Kubalica, E.C.L., pburka, Steven DuBois, SanFranAnnie, Ahron de Leeuw, hoyasmeg, daryl_mitchell, Anonymous9000, dualiti.net, Leimenide, antonella.beccaria, simonwilliamsim, Terrazzo, hillels, valeehill, seaternity, Wonder woman0731, aehdeschaine, Martin Pettitt, Michela Simoncini, RonAlmog, wackybadger, Illusive Photography, Ladycliff, selenas_stock, Stefans02, Borja García de Sola Fernández, La Citta Vita, Esparta, · Sacramento ·, h.koppdelaney, osiristhe, Counselman Collection, Brett Jordan, RonAlmog, Chajm, WordRidden, symphony of love, archer10 (Dennis), Efenstor, Libertinus, Julie, Dave & Family, tedeytan, RL Smith Amateur Photography, michael_swan, mattlemmon, Belzie, Stephen G Pearson, VeryScaryMonkey, krossbow, HonestReporting.com, nikilok, steffenz, JeepersMedia, happymillerman, kleuske, Patty Mooney, Viator.com, Doug Kline, Faith @101, Mr Moss, kidzactivities, Tambako the Jaguar, Marion Doss, quinn.anya, Johnny Silvercloud, fronx, Leonard J Matthews, futureatlas.com, 305 Seahill, BobMacInnes, hawkflight1066, Got Credit, Patty Mooney, frankieleon, Kevin Doncaster, quinn.anya, www.audio-luci-store.it, FindYourSearch, xJason.Rogersx, Elizabeth/Table4Five, HRYMX, Mark A. Nakasone, Mesposito92, anokarina, Kevin M. Gill, vidalia_11, Flare, One Way Stock, allispossible.org.uk, gagilas, torbakhopper, jemasmith, Visual Content, I woz ere, John Drake Flickr, You As A Machine, Sustainable Economies Law Center, Tambako the Jaguar, haldean, futureshape, qnr, PATV Channel 18 Iowa City, Andrew Aliferis, One Way Stock, Yair Aronshtam, Darlin'J